Posted Nov 20, 2018 by Michael L. Brown

The magnitude of the recent California forest fires tragedy is staggering. As of this writing, the confirmed number of dead is more than 80 and the number still missing almost 700.

That means at least 80 people were burned alive in the blazing inferno. Wrap your mind around that for a moment, if you can.

And it’s possible that number could double. Or triple. Or quadruple. Or more. Much more.

Young andold wiped out in a moment of time. Families torn apart forever in this world.Your very worst nightmare replayed over and over again.

What a terrible, terrible tragedy. What an unspeakable disaster.

And along with the loss of life, there is the loss of property, with thousands of homes totally destroyed.

Where was God during this season of devastation and loss?

While we grieve with the survivors and their families, how do we explain such calamities?

I humbly suggest that this is not the time for cheap answers or frivolous speculation. Do you agree?

There are some devout people of faith (including Jews, Christians, and Muslims) who believe that everything that happens is ordained by God for a purpose, however mysterious that purpose might be. Nothing that happens is random, and even acts of human evil have some level of divine rationale, since God does not, in fact, stop the acts.

While this is not my own perspective, I do respect this as a posture of serious faith, echoing the plaintive words of Abraham, “Shall not the Judge of all the earth do right?” (See Genesis 18:25.)

If you are a religious Jew, the first thing you say upon hearing of a death is, “Blessed are You, Lord our God, King of the Universe, the righteous Judge.”

You acknowledge that only God gives life and takes life, hence your first response is one of worship.

Similarly, Calvinist Christians would readily echo the words of Job. He responded to the loss of all his possessions, and, infinitely more importantly, the loss of all his 10 children, with these words: “Naked I came from my mother's womb, and naked shall I return. The LORD gave, and the LORD has taken away; blessed be the name of the LORD” (Job 1:21).

Committed Muslims as well would acknowledge that whatever happens is Allah’s will, be it a forest fire or a glorious sunset.

Again, I respect this faith perspective, and I understand the scriptural arguments behind it. I’m just not ready to say that these terrible forest fires happened simply becauseGod decreed they would happen.

After all, there was a terrible storm one day when Jesus was in the boat with His disciples, but He rebuked the wind and the waves, saying, “Peace be still!” Did Jesus rebuke what His Father willed? That makes very little sense. (See Mark 4:35-40.)

Some Christians see all natural disasters as acts of divine judgment, quickly pointing the finger at the sin of California.

If that is your personal view, may I ask if you’d feel the same if your church-going grandparents were among the dead? Would you be so quick to pronounce judgment if your best friend was killed?

I fully accept that God does send judgment into the earth, right until this day. And I recognize that, when a nation sins, the innocent will suffer as well. And surely our sins, as a nation, are great.

I simply urge you to think twice (or, perhaps twenty or thirty times) before deciding that you know the will of the Lord in this situation. Sometimes silence really is golden.

Others believe that it is the devil alone who kills and destroys, pointing to his murderous acts in Job 1 and 2 (although with divine permission), saying that he is the one behind tragedies like this (see John 8:44, which speaks of his evil nature).

But it is an odd theology which believes that Satan has this kind of power and yet depicts the all-powerful God as merely sitting idly by. Is this the God of the Bible?

And that brings us full circle to our fundamental question: What was the Lord doing when California burned?

Some would say this is a human issue, not a divine issue, since the Lord has given us free will and our choices have serious consequences.

Accordingly, some on the left would blame the right for not paying attention to manmade climate change, pointing to the negative effect this is having on the environment. As one story claims, “As the world warms, we can expect more wildfires.”

Conversely, some on the right would blame extreme environmentalists for blocking the proper treatment of the forests, leading directly to the tragedy.In the words of Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke, “I will lay this on the foot of those environmental radicals that have prevented us from managing the forests for years and, you know what, this is on them.”

So, is this a manmade disaster rather than a God-ordained (or Satan-inspired) disaster?

Barring definitive information on the ground or divine revelation (includingindisputable scriptural insight) from above, I recommend putting our hand over our mouths and praying.The losses are just too great and the agony too acute to sit in the comfort of our homes and speculate.

But that doesn’t mean that we have nothing to say, and it is Jesus Himself who shows us the way to move forward.

We read in John 9 that, when Jesus’ disciples saw a man born blind, they asked Him who sinned, the man or his parents. (In some ancient Jewish teaching, it was believed that you could sin in the womb, explaining how the disciples thought that, perhaps, the man was responsible for his own blindness.)

How did the Lord reply?

“Neither this man nor his parents sinned,”Jesus answered. “This came about so that God's works might be displayed in him.We must do the works of Him who sent Me while it is day. Night is coming when no one can work. As long as I am in the world, I am the light of the world.” (John 9:3-5; see also John 11:1-4 for a parallel perspective.)

Do you grasp the significance of His words?

While Jesus does say that neither the man nor his parents were responsible for his blindness, He does not give a clear explanation of why the man was born blind. Instead, He states that this happened “so that God's works might be displayed in him.”

The blindness was an opportunity for the Lord to be glorified.Sickness, whatever its cause, was an opportunity for divine healing to be displayed. The darkness of human pain only highlighted the light of God’s grace.

And so, we can look into the eyes of the suffering and grieving and say, “I can’t tell you why this happened, but I can tell you that, in the midst of the agony and devastation, God can be glorified. Let’s work together with Him to bring light out of darkness, life out of death, and hope out of despair.”

As impossible as it seems, as acute as the pain may be, and recognizing that nothing will bring back those who have perished, with the Lord greater good can come out of these tragic fires. Let us pursue that greater good with Him.

(For a radio show devoted to this topic, go here.)

Sign Up or Login to post comments.


user profile
Steevo posted a comment · Nov 30, 2018
Paul says we look at heaven through a glass darkly, and I've concluded we look at earth through a glass darkly as well—we just forget. Our eyes only see matter, and we probably only detect one millionth of the spiritual activity behind the material scene. Our entire life is a fight of faith, and our enemies are invisible because they are spiritual, not flesh and blood. It's never a defeat to say "I don't know." Often it is a gross error to say your theology has an answer to all the mysteries, as in Job's comforters. Job himself was extremely frustrated with God for the unexplained calamities that befell him. The prophets and psalmists bemoaned the "seeing through a glass darkly" condition as they exclaimed "Why, Lord, do you reject me and hide your face from me? Why have you forsaken me? Why have you deceived me?" Our mission on earth isn't an intellectual pursuit to know the answer to everything. Our mission is to act, speak, and think in love, mixed with faith. Much of it will explicitly contradict our human logic, such as loving your enemies, doing good, and lending to them, expecting nothing in return. So is God's specific judgement supposed to be obvious to us? Most Christians haven't even figured out what is God's specific will for their life is. Wouldn't it be grand if we were granted the insight to clearly understand God's will as well as His judgments minute by minute without ever having our faith and endurance tested by the long dark nights? That's like getting the answer sheet at the same time you're given the test. But that would defeat the purpose of our quest to perfect faith through trials, suffering and even bewilderment.
Deancooper posted a comment · Nov 21, 2018
I'm thinking we need to do much better than just say, "I don't know why this happened". After all, if this was an act of God's judgement, shouldn't we know that? Don't we need to warn people? "Gee, fire and brimstone are raining down on us, but we don't know why". Does God really expect us to be this ignorant? Won't God judge us for failing to have discernment -- or at least for failing to seek Him for the answers? You're a preeminent Bible scholar, Dr. Brown. Are you saying we're just in the dark on this subject? For me, the answer would be closer to saying God may be lifting His hand of protection off of us. This happened after the election after all. In California. You wrote the commentary on Job, didn't Satan complain that he couldn't touch Job because God was protecting him? In that case, the lifting of protection was in order to prove Job's faithfulness, but surely it must get removed for other reasons as well. Note that if God did remove His protection -- or really just a measure of His protection -- from California, wouldn't that mean that the enemy can now go in and destroy things? Wouldn't that mean that innocent people would be hurt. In the same way, we are all to a degree under the protection of our government. If our government does stupid things, like how it managed the forests, won't innocent people pay the price? My point here is that we could sure use real wisdom. At all levels. And real answers. People really are being hurt. Isn't that motivation enough to get this right? Shouldn't we be pursuing wisdom?